CV & Testimonials
Over the course of my career, I have been fortunate to work with exceptional clients, colleagues, and members of the profession. I am grateful for the generosity of the words shared below, which reflect the values I have sought to uphold throughout my working life: professionalism, careful preparation, sound judgment, and respect for the craft of legal practice.
Court of Appeal Judge
“Your journey as a legal practitioner has been marked with distinction, dedication and exemplary fidelity to the values of excellence. You stepped into the shoes of legal giants to lead Armstrongs for many years and it flourished under your leadership and guidance.
It was always a pleasure to have you appear in our courts. Punctuality, precision and thorough preparation of your court papers as well as the respect, decorum, and an open but firm mind were traits one hoped many young practitioners would emulate for their development. These ingrained qualities will no doubt continue to inspire many as you transition in your professional life.”
Chambers & Partners
Star Individual: Dispute Resolution
Dispute Resolution - Botswana
“Managing partner John Carr-Hartley is one of Botswana's foremost disputes practitioners, with a wealth of experience in both litigation and arbitration. He handles a broad range of mandates, including commercial litigation as well as construction disputes.”
Quotes from Clients
Mariam Tapela – Head of Dispute Resolution, Debswana Diamond Company
"I have had the opportunity to work with John on matters involving the FIDIC Suite of Contracts and complex drilling projects, mining related projects and construction-related disputes. Throughout our engagements, he consistently demonstrated a deep understanding of FIDIC principles, contractual risk allocation, claims management, and dispute resolution processes. He has been instrumental in providing robust and practical advice in complex matters such as early under-ground works, advising in underground contracts and providing training on FIDIC Suite of Contracts.
John’s ability has a talent for efficiency and timely delivery, while paying attention to detail and being thorough in his work. His ability to analyse technical and contractual issues objectively, coupled with his practical appreciation of project realities, enables him to deal effectively with disputes in a fair, balanced, and commercially sensible manner. I have found him to be passionate about his work, knowledgeable, professional, and independent in his approach, and I would have confidence in him in all general legal matters, especially those involving construction and infrastructure projects, including disputes arising under FIDIC contracts."
"John Carr-Hartley is an excellent lawyer who is able to provide solutions to any legal matter. He is always available when needed for advice."
"John is the kind of lawyer you want on your complex matters. He pays attention to detail and is extremely organised."
Former Colleagues
“We must also say that we are very sorry to see you retire from Armstrongs. Over the years it has been a privilege working with you and benefiting from your professionalism.
Your contribution to your firm and to the profession over the past 36 years is remarkable, and it is clear from your note how meaningful those years have been – you can be proud.
We wish you every success in your next role as an arbitrator and have no doubt that the same wisdom and experience that served your clients so well will continue to do so in this new capacity.”
“You truly deserve our gratitude for your immeasurable contribution to the profession in general and development of some of us in particular for which we will remain ever so grateful.”
“Your race in this chapter is run, and what a trail you have left in your wake.
From when first we met in 2007 to date, you have been a teacher, you became a friend, and you were always both the example and the grindstone. For each of these I thank you, John. You gave freely, and likely unknowingly, but I suppose that that is what makes a legacy, especially the parts that were not performative by their nature.
Though I am sad that you will no longer be in this part of the game, I am excited and rooting for you in whatever comes next. I will be sure to engage you qua senior counsel, and as an arbitrator.”
“You may soon be gone but will not be forgotten. I am delighted to hear of your plans to enroll as Advocate and to also arbitrate. It will be good for the Botswana legal fraternity to retain your knowledge and skills and continue learning from its masters.”
“Hi John, I don’t think you appreciate how amazing you’ve been. I’ve personally learnt a lot from you. You pay attention to detail, apply yourself, are meticulous in your approach coupled with your exceptional intelligence and wisdom. You are a master at the craft and the solutions you tailor for clients are practical and applicable.
I truly am thankful that I didn’t just get to meet you but that I worked with you. I like to think I have grown a bit in my journey since I’ve met you and part of that is because of the lessons I learn from you and from working with you.”
“Hi SC. I am really happy to hear about your retirement. Not because I don’t respect you and not because I want you to leave the profession. On the contrary the reason is that every time I see a Pleading signed by you, I go “oh shit.” I wish you well SC”